Cultures, Values and Beliefs... Who's Right?

I am terrified when watching the news each night: the growing tensions and terrorisms, the conflicts and the chaos. It seems so foreign to me. It seems helpless and hopeless and so far removed from the world that I inhabit. I believe that people are essentially good, that they are not malicious or evilly inclined. It may be a naïve view of the world, but it allows me to sleep at night and makes me empathetic of those around me rather than suspicious. I’m certainly of the view that we are “all in this together,” and would stop to help someone on the street if they were in distress. 

I saw a recent cartoon that showed a man sitting in front of a television that screamed “WHAT CAN WE DO TO LESSEN THE FEAR OF TERRORISM?!?!” and then showed this man turning off his TV set and appearing very pleased with his decision. Although I agree with this approach to a certain extent, the saying that came into my mind was “ignorance is bliss.” I am not sure that by simply switching off our televisions, we are actually making enough of a positive impact on the world… at least not in the sense of working towards a peaceful, harmonious future for humanity. 

This morning, I had a Skype conversation with some teachers at an Indonesian “national plus” school, to try and arrange some collaboration between our classes. These are teachers who work with Indonesian students, but using an international curriculum, hopefully preparing them for international universities in the future. Like me, these teachers are educators of seven and eight year old students. We are peacemakers on a daily basis, but only in terms of solving classroom and school yard problems, generally: like someone not sharing their lego or taking someone else’s biscuits. The unit that we are hoping to collaborate through is based on values and beliefs. One of the teachers, Ibu Nury was concerned about the sensitive nature of the topic, and wanted to make sure that we could all proceed without offending anyone or making any students upset. It’s a very valid point, students of this age are developmentally just beginning to realise that they are not the centre of the universe. That there are people who may challenge the views that they have always taken as gospel (so to speak).  What they have been taught, or have absorbed from their family environments is what they often believe to be factual, and it’s around this age that they begin to be challenged by other ideas, by other children who feel just as strongly about their own values and beliefs. 

I believe that this collaboration is a great opportunity to allow these students to safely explore their values and beliefs in a supportive environment. If it’s done effectively, it could be the beginning of some students seeing the world from other perspectives. It will be brilliant to be a part of allowing these children to explore how Indonesian and Hong Kong cultures are very, very different, and not just from a religious point of view. But essentially, we are allowing eight-year-old children to connect.  

My hope is that we can expose these children to completely different cultures, values, traditions and beliefs. If we do this well, it may allow them the opportunity to see that other perspectives can be very different, but can be equally right or important. That these varieties of perspectives can provide the diversity that makes this world wonderful. That we can co-exist harmoniously and peacefully side-by-side: that we don’t have to fight to show who is more powerful, more influential or more right. At eight years old, that’s a pretty powerful realization.

I believe, above all that it’s not just about tolerance, but understanding, acceptance and love of humanity – no matter where people are from, how they dress or who they pray to. Not hiding away, believing that ignorance is bliss. But exploring the concept that true understanding of other cultures, beliefs and people can show that knowledge is power, and that’s much more powerful than turning off the television any day of the week.

With this hope, and the strength of my own beliefs and values (that people are essentially good…) I hope I can be a little less terrified when I watch the news tonight, and see the death toll of the latest bombing. Or maybe I will turn the television off instead and go for a walk outside…

Upon Reflection

Upon reflection - most things are easier, make more sense, have a better comeback, are more enlightening or more worthwhile. Reflection gives us the chance to stop, think back and put things into perspective. To think of things we may have done differently given the same chance again. Reflection can be heartbreaking, soul-destroying, hope-giving, exhilarating or anything in between. Reflection gives us something that never exists in the actual moment – the chance to stop the clock and really think.

Have you ever done something that really tested you – physically, mentally?  I remember completing a 50km walk years ago with some great friends, and although completely under-prepared, we found ourselves lost and tired in the darkening night. It was anything but fun. My feet hurt, my bones were tired, I was hungry, cold and running out of positivity fast. Upon reflection, those hours were amongst the most valuable bonding times I have spent with those friends – we now reminisce on our experience and double over in laughter at the times we had whilst wandering around the hills, wondering if we would ever finish the course!

Professional reflection is important too. As a teacher, I have NEVER stood back at the end of the day and said to myself “Wow, I really nailed it today. I did everything perfectly and it all went to plan!” It just does not happen. Sure, there are times at the end of a session when I feel like the kids really “got it” or we made some good connections or discussed something really valuable. But that is invariably followed up by someone poking someone else in the eye, calling someone a baby or another disaster of such magnitude.  

In all seriousness – reflection is the way that I plan my way ahead. Looking back to look forward – if that makes any sense?! I learned about a great theory from Wiggins & McTighe – whose theory of Backwards Design is incredibly wise: It seems so simple – where do we want to finish up? Start with that. Then, plot my way there. What do I need to do for the students to achieve success at that end point? How can I support them to get there? What have we done before that has worked well? How much can they achieve in the time allocated? The cycle of action and reflection is literally endless.

And I wonder why I find it hard to still my mind at night! What could I have done differently for those students who just didn’t get it? How else could I have said that? What activities could have been richer, more engaging, better structured?

If I let my thoughts run away, I would never think about anything else, and in all honesty – that’s one of my biggest challenges this year. But reflection is important for my development as a teacher, and I think as long as I use reflection as a tool to keep pursuing more engaging, more relevant, more authentic learning – I guess I am heading in the right direction. Reaching for continuous improvement is giving my students the best chance of success. That’s what it’s really all about.

At the end of a particularly rewarding session last week, I was rewarded with a golden comment from one of my students – one that will remain with me for a long time: “Mrs D, you made me so smart.” To which I replied, “no I didn’t – you did that, I just helped you to ask better questions.”

Upon reflection – I hope that gives you the same warm fuzzy it gave me…

Until next time – tell your reflection that it’s special.